Why is our bigger Tesla more efficient?

Our Model Y is taller, wider and heavier than the Model 3 it replaced, and it rolls on 20-inch open wheels where the Model 3 had 18s under aero covers. All of that should cost it energy. But, somehow it uses less: 139 Wh/km against the Model 3's 145. We are not sure why.

Somebody asked about it on our last post, and it is worth chasing: efficiency was one of our main criteria when we went looking for a new car. The Kia EV5 was roomy and boxy and poor on efficiency. The XPeng G6 came closest, and matched the Model Y on claimed efficiency. We stayed with Tesla for the storage, the drive and the tech.

Both our cars were/are the standard range RWD, the entry model, and we bought them that way on purpose: we wanted to know whether the most basic EV covers what most people actually drive. It does. Tesla now sells a Model 3 Long Range claiming up to 750 km.

The log does show where the difference is. Sorting all 125,000 km by how fast each car was moving at the time, the Model Y uses less in every speed band below 90 km/h, by 6 to 10 Wh/km. Above 90 they swap places: the faster we go, the more aerodynamics matters, and shape is the one thing the Model 3 does better. So whatever the Model Y is doing better, it is not about air.

The brochures say the opposite. Our Model 3 was quoted 491 km on a full charge, and our Model Y's own windscreen label says 466. Our driving gave the Model 3 395 km and gives the Model Y 414.

Real world use rarely matches claimed range. But we got 81% of the Model 3's claim and we get 89% of the Model Y's. Same size battery, bigger car, 19 km further.

Does anyone know why our Model Y gets further on the same juice?

Charging

All of this comes out of EEVEE, the app that has logged both cars since December 18, 2022 — 125,204 km of travel. It works out energy from the battery percentage, so what it really measures is how much battery a kilometre costs. That only compares fairly if the two batteries are the same size, and these are: 62.3 kWh against 62.5.

Related Posts

Share via

16 comments

  1. I took our aeros off a long time ago, they are so ugly, we haven’t noticed a difference in range but in saying that we don’t check haha we just did Mackay to Wollongong and back 2 weeks ago.
    3

    Reply Report

    1. Kylie Gilroy Oh, wow. I thought they were supposed to add about 4% range.

      Reply Report

      1. Tesla Tripping I have no idea, also depends on road conditions and the weather I guess, 4% is nothing really.
        2

        Reply Report

  2. Just love your figures
    Ours does 13.5kwh/100
    1

    Reply Report

    1. Kevin Powers Nice! Model Y? What year?

      Reply Report

  3. More efficient motors would be my guess, I belive tesla have improved their efficiency.
    1

    Reply Report

  4. Your juniper has more efficient motor.They do not use same motors check your vin’s
    1

    Reply Report

  5. It's just the tyres
    1

    Reply Report

    1. Karl Jensen How so? The 20” wheels/tyres on the Model Y are supposed to give worse efficiency. 🤔
      1

      Reply Report

      1. Tesla Tripping **TYRES**
        EG new base model Tesla gets longer range than the RWD premium.
        They make the sidewalls stiffer and the treads harder and with more gaps
        This has less rubber on the road less grip and less drag.

        Personally I don't think it's worth it I run my cars around with flat tyres 3P I run at 36psi on 18" wheels
        The ride is better, the grip is better, even wear across the treads is better but the efficiency is less.

        If I run it around at 46psi cold on Hankook ion EVo AS 600 TW tyres it would do 140Wh vs the 180Wh I get now.

        Simply not a sacrifice I'm prepared to make.
        3

        Reply Report

      2. Karl Jensen Repeating the word doesn’t make it clearer what you mean 😉. Do you mean compound, diameter, rolling resistance, weight, grip, aerodynamics, etc? Both cars came with the tyres provided by Tesla.

        Reply Report

      3. Tesla Tripping Yep and your model Y has different sizes and different compounds to the model 3.
        Your model 3 likely came with a pilot Sport4 a ripper performance tyre that's built to make the car grip and handle not something to get a number on a brochure.
        If your current car has Hankooks they are rubbish in comparison for performance and grip but excel for tread wear and efficiency
        1

        Reply Report

      4. You called the Model 3 exactly right. Michelin Pilot Sport 4, 235/45R18 98Y, in Tesla's T0 spec. Tesla's invoice for the replacement set names the part.

        The Y isn't on Hankooks though. Michelin Pilot Sport EV, 255/40R20. Tesla's service message gave us the brand and size when we had the flat last Christmas, and the sidewall in our own photos says Pilot Sport EV.

        So, same family, different job. The 3's tyre is built for grip. The Y's is Michelin's EV version, built to trade a little of that for range.

        Whether it explains the whole 6.4 Wh/km is another matter. Both tyres carry a B on the EU label for rolling resistance, which puts them within about 1 kg/t of each other, and the Y is 90 to 160 kg heavier. That gets us maybe half to three quarters of the way, not all of it.

        It does land where you'd expect, though. The Y is ahead in every speed band under 90, and behind above it. Rolling resistance at low speed, aerodynamics at high. So, tyres are the biggest single thing we can point at, and you got there first.

        The Model 3 tyre replacement, if you're curious:
        New tyres for our Tesla Model 3
        11

        Reply Report

  6. Improvements in efficiency, maybe the 3 radiator needs a clean. Maybe driven differently
    1

    Reply Report

    1. Cameron Smith All possible. Although probably not radiator since the efficiency didn’t get worse over time.
      1

      Reply Report

  7. I can absolutely confirm that our November 2025 LR Y is more efficient than our 2019 Model 3 (stealthy P, with 18” wheels), and by a significant margin.

    It’s just down to great engineering I guess.
    (I’m blown away with the efficiency of the Y.)
    11

    Reply Report

Leave a comment