Great place to charge... if you can

Yanakie Hall is a near ideal place to stop. It is on the road into Wilsons Promontory, which is the only road in or out, so everyone going to the park passes the door.

The hall shares Lance Moon Park with a playground, two tennis courts, picnic tables, a toilet block and a lot of lawn under the trees, looking out over farmland. Wilsons Prom Pizza is across the road, and the Yanakie General Store is a few hundred metres up the main road.

There are solar panels on the hall roof, which no doubt add to the grid supply for the EV charger in the car park. Surely the perfect place to charge, right?

Charging

We had more than enough charge to get back to the camp ground at Waratah Bay. I wanted extra, to cover the air conditioning overnight, cooking, and the first part of the drive home in the morning. The easy answer would have been to plug in at the camp ground, but we were not on a powered site.

There was a Kia EV9 on the charger when we pulled in, and no way of telling how long it would be there. The station has two cables, but one of them is CHAdeMO, an older connector that modern EVs do not use, so in practice there is one.

I knew this station had a history. PlugShare carried a run of reports from the week before, all saying the same thing: nobody could start the CCS2. One driver had tried six times, rung Chargefox, had the unit reset, and still got nothing. Another gave up and drove to the Evie charger at Fish Creek. But here was an EV9 plugged in and charging, so I took that as a sign someone had been out and fixed it. We were passing anyway, so I thought I would try my luck.

The EV9 driver had not checked into PlugShare with an estimated charge time. The Chargefox app was more help: it gave me their charge percentage and how many minutes ago they had started. What it could not give me was when they would finish, which I guess would need their charging rate and their battery size.

So, I did it the old fashioned way. I got out of my car, walked over to theirs, waved, smiled, and asked how long he thought he would be. Ten minutes, to 80%. I had things to catch up on anyway, so we waited.

When he left, I plugged in, and the charger and the app both made all the right noises. But no actual charging. I tried a few times, with the app and with the RFID card.

I rang Chargefox support. They worked through some questions, including whether all the doors and windows were closed, which seemed weird. Then they rebooted the unit and told me to try again in seven minutes and call them back. I did, it failed again, and I called back. They escalated it, said the station had a history of problems that its owner had not yet arranged to fix, and told me I would have to find somewhere else to charge.

Chargefox runs the app and the payments, not the hardware. It got out of the charging equipment business in 2023, and its agreement with a site owner now requires them to have a maintenance contract, service the station at least once every twelve months, and produce a plan to fix anything that breaks. This one belongs to the South Gippsland Shire Council, which installed six fast chargers around the shire with state and federal grant money and charges 57c per kWh to cover both the electricity and the maintenance. So, rebooting it was about as far as the person on the phone could go for me.

This is one of the very few times we have had trouble this bad with a public charger. A few years ago several on the so called Queensland Electric Super Highway (QESH) were out of action for weeks at a time, which I think came down to the owner not arranging a service contract as part of the much hyped installation.

Ten days on, the Chargefox app still shows both ports at Yanakie as faulted, with a note that the station is experiencing intermittent issues and is under investigation with the station owner. I left a check-in of my own on PlugShare, and it is still the most recent one on the station.

Back to PlugShare. There were fast chargers a little out of the way, and a slower destination charger listed at the Men’s Shed in Sandy Point, twenty minutes up the road and kind of on our way. It was getting near dinner, so I decided to risk the slow one while we cook a meal. What could possibly go wrong?

Related Posts

Links

  • PlugShare check-ins for the Yanakie Hall charger plugshare.com
  • South Gippsland Shire Council’s six EV chargers, at 57c/kWh covering the electricity and their maintenance southgippsland.vic.gov.au
  • Chargefox divested from charging hardware in 2023 to run the software platform chargefox.com
  • Chargefox’s Site Host terms: a maintenance arrangement, and preventative maintenance every 12 months support.chargefox.com
  • What Chargefox does when a station faults: a remediation plan, and removal from the network after 30 days support.chargefox.com
Share via

1 comment

  1. We had issues with ChargeFox DC chargers in western Queensland just over a year ago - Hughenden comes to mind. That charger had been out of action for months when we got there. Out there it is a long way to the next charger if you come across a defective one. Fortunately, we were able to get by using AC chargers but we were annoyed by the poor service.

    ChargeFox appears to be just a payment system, a third party actually owns and is responsible for maintaining the charger. So if the charger is defective it is difficult for the EV driver to directly get in touch with the maintainer. As a result, I steer clear of ChargeFox chargers when I can and when I can’t have a Plan B up my sleeve.
    11

    Reply Report

Leave a comment